"Ask the Rabbi" by R. Mermelstein

What is your opinion on the best type of handgun for self defense for a novice. I have heard many opinions in the revolver vs. pistol debate and I value yours tremendously. Which one would you choose and then if you say revolver, which would be the best one for personal self defense or likewise which pistol would you say is the best. I am looking for something that I could conceal easily.

Thank you,

Michael Bloom

Novice or expert, a self defense handgun must be chambered for a caliber that has a proven track record of success in actual shooting confrontations. This may put some first time gun owners in a catch 22 situation. They have never handled firearms and want to make an immediate jump to a serious caliber before learning to master firearms rudiments that are best gotten from a caliber that will not be distracting or intimidating by virtue of its recoil, the .22 being the perfect example. In any violent altercation, anyone is scared. They would be trying to look macho if they claimed otherwise. The training you receive must become second nature to the point where you act on instinct.

I like both auto loading pistols and revolvers, alike. There is no valid reason for a beginner to shy away from an autoloader. The modern double action auto loading pistol is very "revolver like" in its characteristics and I don't believe one type of gun requires any less training than another.

If you like revolvers, Smith & Wesson has their small J-frame Models 442, 638, 649, and 60; the latter two having the capability to use .357 Magnum ammunition as well as .38 Special. The first two have alloy frames which make them lighter to carry.

If autoloaders are your preference, there are too many to list. It seems that the small frame Glock pistols with polymer frames in 9 mm and 40 S&W, the Model 26 and 27, have an immense following.

Whatever your choice, get ample training from a qualified instructor. Then, practice, practice, practice!

Sincerely,

R. Mermelstein