"Ask the Rabbi
" by R. Mermelstein



QUESTION: Dear Rabbi Mermelstein:

I have chosen the 1911 type pistol as my self defense carry weapon. I have a Colt Commander with an aluminum frame that I like very much, and it carries well all day long. I have been advised that the aluminum frame guns should be used for carry only, with an all steel gun used for practice -- the theory being that the aluminum frame is subject to excessive wear and aging leading to failure. What is your opinion on this matter? Thank you for your time.

Sincerely,

Jonathan Hoffman
4 Jun 1999



ANSWER:
Dear Sir,

Extensive tests of endurance have been run on pistols with aluminum alloy frames. They have fared quite well. They are not as fragile as many would have you believe. I've seen steel 1911 frames crack around the hole used for the slide stop/release. Put it in perspective: Will you use your Colt Commander to fire in excess of 10,000 rounds a year? The U.S. Government considers the life of a Beretta 92 to be 8,000 rounds. That number was stipulated in the original test requirements when the U.S. armed services were evaluating sidearms to replace the venerable 1911A1  A former associate shot an all-steel Browning Hi Power to pieces, literally. Browning, in Ogden, UT, returned the bag of pieces with a note that the gun was out of warranty since "it was fired too much"! Always use a good quality lubricant on the frame and slide at all contact points. My favorite is Lubriplate 630-AA. Don't bother looking for it in gun shops. It's only sold in places that sell machine bearings. Contact their corporate headquarters at:

129 Lockwood St.
Newark, NJ 07105
PHONE: 800-733-4755
FAX: 973-589-4432

See their web site at http://www.lubriplate.com/. This lube really works and stays put!

Sincerely,

R. Mermelstein


Click here to write Rabbi Mermelstein your questions!

[Back to Home Page] [Copyright, Contact & Credits]

[Back to "Ask the Rabbi"]